How Does Division of Property and Debt Work During Divorce?

The dissolution of a marriage is never easy. Divorce not only has deep emotional and psychological impact, but its financial ramifications can dictate how the future plays out for both people involved.  

Dividing the family’s property during divorce can be quite complicated. This holds especially true if there are significant assets involved - houses, retirement and pension plans, stocks, deferred compensation, brokerage accounts, businesses, professional practices, licenses, rental properties and a lot more. Add to this the debt acquired during the marriage that has to be divided.

Even under the most amenable separations, decisions on who gets what and who pays for which can be quite a challenge. And it’s much worse, of course, if the divorce is contentious.

Division of Property and Debt in California

California is classified as a “Community Property’ state and is one of only 9 states that recognize community property law. Under this law, both spouses are treated as equal co-owners of both property and debt acquired during marriage. 

In a divorce, the court will rule that community property and debts be divided equally between the spouses in divorce. While it is not always possible to divide all assets and debts in half (like in the case of a family home, for example), the ultimate result is an equal distribution.

Debts may or may not be equally divided depending on several determining factors, including the amount of assets each spouse receives. A larger portion of the debt may be assigned to the spouse who receives more property. As an example, if one spouse retains the marital home, he or she may be required by law to assume the mortgage. However, the other spouse may agree to pay the mortgage in exchange for not paying alimony.

There are exceptions to the Community Property Law:

1)   Prior arrangement between spouses on how properties and assets will be divided like in the case of a prenuptial agreement, for instance

2)    If the value of the community debt exceeds the value of the community assets. For this, unequal division of debts is allowed with the excess debts assigned to the spouse who is in a better financial situation to pay them. 

However a couple decides to divide properties or debts - be it on their own or via court decision, there are 3 crucial steps to the process:

1)    Determination of nature of properties or debts - marital (community) or separate

2)    Agreement on value of marital or community property

3)    Decision on how to divide the property or debt

Community vs Separate Property or Debt

In order to better understand how property is divided, it helps to know how properties are classified. It is important to note that properties mean not only real properties but also include other assets, that are easy to overlook.  Some examples are:

  • Tax refunds 

  • 401(k)s, 

  • IRAs and other retirement plans, 

  • Deferred compensation, 

  • Stock options, restricted stocks and other equity, 

  • Bonuses and commissions, 

  • Country club memberships, 

  • Annuities and life Insurance, 

  • brokerage accounts such mutual funds, stocks, bonds, etc; 

In California, there are 3 recognized types of property classifications for married couples:

1)    Community Property.  California law defines community property as “all property, real or personal, wherever situated, acquired by a married person during the marriage while domiciled in this state.” 

2)   Quasi-community Property. Much like the above, quasi-community property are those owned or acquired in another state prior to a married couple’s move to California. Under California law, this property is treated like community property.

3)   Separate Property.  The third classification refers to property or properties acquired before the marriage OR after the divorce process. This is not included in the equal division of properties. The following are considered separate properties:

    a)    Any property owned by either spouse prior to the marriage;

    b)    An inheritance received by either spouse before or after the marriage;

    c)    A gift received by the husband or wife from a third party;

    d)    Payment received for pain and suffering portion in a personal injury judgment

Debts are similarly classified as Community Debt or Separate Debt. Community debts are those incurred after the date of marriage. These debts belong to both spouses equally even if only one spouse incurred them. 

On the other hand, Separate debts are those incurred before the marriage or after separation. These belong only to the spouse that incurred them.

It Is Not All Cut and Dried …. The Process Can Be Complicated

The division of properties and debt is a complicated area of law because not everything is black or white. Even determination of what constitutes community or separate property and debt can become muddled. 

For instance, a spouse may unintentionally change a separate asset into a community asset by “co-mingling” separate property with marital property. This can happen, for example, to a house that was owned by one spouse. If both spouses pay the mortgage and other expenses on it, it becomes a marital property. Or in the case of a premarital bank account belonging to one spouse - it likewise becomes community property if the other spouse makes deposits to it.

There are also certain types of assets that are partially community and partially separate. This can happen if one spouse owns a business or other asset to which the other actively contributed either by labor input or funds during the marriage. 

The examples above show how things can get complicated and convoluted. In cases where there are a lot of assets and debt involved, hiring a good divorce financial planner can help sort things out. 

In part 2 of this article, we continue with information on steps you can take to protect yourself financially before and during divorce.  Click here to read it.

Tags: community debt, community property. joint property, debt division, property division, debt responsibility, financial responsibility, divorce property division, divorce debt

Filed Under: Divorce Tips

This information is not intended to be a substitute for seeking legal advice from an attorney. For legal or tax advice please seek the services of a qualified attorney and/or qualified tax professional.

Gaining Financial Empowerment Now...

And For The Future

DISCLOSURE

Kimberly Surber is a Certified Financial Planner®  and a Certified Divorce Financial Analyst®; however such registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training and no inference to the contrary should be made. Information presented is for informational purposes only, does not intend to make an offer or solicitation for the sale or purchase of any securities, and should not be considered investment advice.  Kimberly Surber has not taken into account the investment objectives, financial situation or particular needs of any individual investor. There is a risk of loss from an investment in securities, including the risk of loss of principal. Different types of investments involve varying degrees of risk, and there can be no assurance that any specific investment will be profitable or suitable for a particular investor's financial situation or risk tolerance. Asset allocation and portfolio diversification cannot assure or guarantee better performance and cannot eliminate the risk of investment losses. Be sure to first consult with a qualified financial advisor and/or tax professional before implementing any strategy discussed here. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Investments involve risk, including loss of principal and unless otherwise stated, are not guaranteed. Information provided reflects Kimberly Surber's views as of certain time periods, such views are subject to change at any point without notice. For a copy of our Privacy Policy, see below.

Kimberly Surber provides informational articles not intended to be used as the sole basis for financial decisions, nor should it be construed as advice designed to meet the particular needs of an individual's situation. Kimberly Surber is not responsible for the consequences of any decisions or actions taken as a result of information provided in these articles and does not warrant or guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information requested or displayed. External Links are not affiliated with Kimberly Surber.

The Women’s Choice Award Financial Advisor program was created by WomenCertified Inc., the Voice of Women, in an effort to help women make smart financial choices. The program is based on 17 objective criteria associated with providing quality service to women clients such as credentials, experience and a favorable regulatory history, among other factors. Financial advisors do not pay a fee to be considered or placed on the final list of Women’s Choice Award® Financial Advisors, though they may have paid a basic program fee to cover the cost of a client survey through Advisor Impact. The inclusion of a financial advisor within the Women’s Choice Award Financial Advisor network should not be construed as an endorsement of the financial advisor by WomenCertified or its partners and affiliates and is no guarantee as to future investment success. Women’s Choice Award® Financial Advisors and Firms represent less than 1% of financial advisors in the U.S. As of February 2016, of the 783 considered for the Women’s Choice Award, 122 were named Women’s Choice Award Financial Advisors/Firms.

Privacy Policy